« Innovation culture: Predator version | Main | In lieu of a press release »

October 10, 2004

Comments

Jay

I don't doubt the 57% for a couple of reasons. One being that I go to bookstores fairly often (once a week or so)so if something is available there I tend to buy it there. This accounts for most of my buying of top-selling books. Second, I use Amazon specifically to find things that are rare or out-of-print. For all of my Amazon book purchases I know that none of them were available locally. I don't mind paying shipping for something that I can't just go out and buy, but I don't want to pay shipping for something that is in a store that I will go to eventually anyway.

Anonymous

OK, ~25% of Amazon/Netflix content is not stocked in a physical store NOW. How has this been changing and how will it change?

Physical stores rotate content out, on-line stores don't need to. Once it becomes available at Netflix, a movie can be available _forever_ at Netflix.

I see a strong case that, as content leaves physical shelves, on-line sales/rentals can continue to be a viable revenue stream indefinitely.

Books already have second-tier publishers who pick up the rights to publish out-of-print books and we are now seeing the emergence of on-demand publishing for even smaller markets - individual books.

Another comment:
Used book stores are becoming a thing of the past. I can browse more titles more efficiently at Amazon.

praktike

I wish you the best with your book.

One thing I wonder is: how are you going to handle the Google books phenomenon?

rob

Well, this looks like a very interesting subject for a book, there is a LOT here.

Thrity percent seems about right, given my own shopping behavior. Netflix, for example, has Kurosawa's Yojimbo (and it's in my queue right now), but I doubt my local video store has it. On the other hand, I still rent plenty of mainstream movies too.

Looking back to 2003 (for a complete year), I see that I ordered 21 books from Amazon (yikes!), with about seven of them not likely to be in an average bookstore, in my opinion.

But the interesting thing is that some of the books I order are WAY outside of the mainstream. For example, I've long been interested in the history of the cult of the UFO and that led me to books like _Looking for Orthon_, which is a biography of George Adamski, one of the first "contactees" and root source of many crazy UFO ideas. The book has an Amazon sales rank of 718,232!

Rob Hafernik

Well, I run two websites that probably qualify as out on the far end of the tail:

http://www.hafernik.com
http://arabiannightsbooks.com

The first one is a family genealogy site. My parents had spent 25 years collecting the data and I thought it would be fun to make it into a web site. The second is about a hobby of mine, collecting illustrations from the zillions of editions of the Arabian Nights that are out there.

Both of these are about as far out on the tail as anyone would like. But I've noticed something funny about being out on the tail: your traffic is still extremely even. I get 9, 10 or 11 visits to the hafernik.com site every day. It rarely varies and when it does it's usually because *I* was checking on the site.

I don't know if there is math to be done here, but both of my "tail" sites show this behavior.

Tim Walters

-----
He and his team fit a standard Pareto power law distribution to Amazon sales rank and summed the total above 40,000 (the amount of books stocked by the average bookstore).
-----

I don't understand how this translates to "not available in stores," unless you assume that all bookstores carry the same 40,000 books, which is demonstrably not the case.

For example, I just looked up the book I bought (new) in a store yesterday (David Garnett, "Lady Into Fox"). Its Amazon rank is 160,354. Trying for something further down the tail, I checked "The Collected Strange Stories of Robert Aickman" (which I bought at my local science fiction specialty store, and would assume is available at others). Its rank was 1,845,023!

Maybe you mean "not available in crappy chain stores." Which is worth noting, but not at all the same thing.

John Thacker

"Not available in crappy chain stores" is a big deal, though. First off, while plenty of things are available at specialty stores, and things differ by stores, people are still dependent on things being available in their particular area, of having such specialty stores near them.

In other words, it's a version of the old Sears Catalog effect. You don't have to live in a large city to have access to esoteric items anymore. It's extending the range of retail past physical space, into aggregating large populations.

He doesn't mean "crappy chain stores," either, at least not in the sense that I grew up with. The modern Borders and Barnes & Noble stores are a huge improvement over the tiny, unspecialized bookstores (often chains) that I saw growing up. They have an impressive breadth of titles-- but aren't going to be able to match something like Amazon. Nor can local specialty shops unconnected to the Internet match Amazon or any specialty retailer that can aggegrate sales.

However, I have a more important caveat. Perhaps there are lots of users drawn to Amazon, Netflix, and other sites just to buy the rare items. Perhaps they buy the big hits at their local bookstores, record dealers, Blockbuster, whatever, for the immediacy, but then get their niche items online. I know a lot of people with this behavior. It would naturally exaggerate the size of the tail, at least as a percentage of the whole industry. There may always be people who prefer brick-and-mortar for purchasing hits. At least online exists to capture the tail, though, and certainly makes it possible.

Tim Walters

>"Not available in crappy chain stores" is a big deal, though.

Oh, definitely. I just think it's important to know what we're really talking about when we throw around these numbers.

>The modern Borders and Barnes & Noble stores are a huge improvement over the tiny, unspecialized bookstores (often chains) that I saw growing up.

That's true--I remember the B. Dalton's of my youth and shudder. But that also means that Borders and Barnes & Noble provided a long-tail effect of their own when they started becoming popular back in the Eighties, as did Beverages & More, Whole Foods and IKEA in their various sectors. It would be interesting to track the prehistory of the "long tail."

Julian Bond

I'd be interested in similar figures for music.

Rudy

Barnes and Noble online doesn't seem to have nearly as long a "tail"
as Amazon; which is unfortunate for me, given that Amazon gave heavily to the Republicans (please ask Jeff Bezos why!!) and BN gave to the Democrats. (I'd rather these big corporations would stay out of politics altogether, but as long as they using their profits that way, we have to be aware of this when we shop).

Yves

I can't wait until the book comes out. I'd love to see what you discover about the mathematics of the long tail. I did a quick survey of a week's worth of messages from a yahoo group I frequent and found that 14% of the posts were from people who posted 5 times or less in the week. I created a pie chart and the sequence resembled a seashell as the numbers went down from the person who posted the most amount of messages (11%) to the one who posted the least. I'd be curious to know what the long tail mathematics are for social networks.

garces

I don't know if there is math to be done here, but both of my "tail" sites show this behavior

--------------
http://www.bromastelefono.com/

Phil

Interesting notion about the "Prehistory of the long tail". I think the Wired article talked about limited inventories as being a product of early mass production. If we look back further to the days of custom-made items then I would not be surprised if there are some areas (such as furniture) where the variety available then was greater than what we see today.

konbs

---------------
Both of these are about as far out on the tail as anyone would like. But I've noticed something funny about being out on the tail: your traffic is still extremely even. I get 9, 10 or 11 visits to the hafernik.com site every day.
---------------

Er... Web crawlers?

Morris Rosenthal

The link Chris gives to my Amazon sales rank analysis above is still active, but the whole system changed just days after he originally made this post. Amazon completely revamped their sales ranking system in October 2004, right after he wrote the articles, becoming stable right at the beginning of November, when I redid the graph linked above. One effect of Amazon's change was to render all previous rank history meaningless, and all of the academic studies done to that point, including several that referred to my old article, became obsolete as reference material. Whatever conclusions they'd drawn to that point may have been valid, but the new system almost entirely ignores historical sales, as I explained in my December update. For a long time watcher like myself, the orders of magnitudes changes in old "permanent" ranks are what gave away the lack of historical weight in the new system.

I still so quite a bit of Amazon watching in my self publishing blog, and this year, Amazon's international media sales may actually surpass their North American sales. As both a trade author and a self publisher, I can say for sure that you need to stay on the short end of the tail at Amazon to actually make a living at it:-)

Miles

As with any stat, the definition is paramount. Back in '99, amazon was selling several hundreds of thousands of unique book titles each month and over 80% of those titles did not appear on the sales list the following month. So, if a physical megastore only carries 25-40k unique titles, it isn't carrying 90% of the titles that amazon sells in a month.

missliang
amazon

通販システムでカードでお金、クレジットカード 現金化です。
アダルトグッズ激安通販。
不動産融資では多様化するお客様のあらゆるニーズに迅速・適確・誠実にお応え致し、
32年の実績と信頼があります。

Hot Deals

amazon is always good for dealing but i mostly find my product from here http://www.dealshunt.com, they offer good service and cheap price.

Best Deals

I wish you the best with your book !!.I think the above article talked about limited inventories as being a product of early mass production.

zol

楽天レンタル
goo net
山の手形成クリニック
マネースクウェア
セルシーフィット
ピュアリープリズム
ロシア株 証券会社
エキサイト恋愛結婚
エキサイト恋愛結婚
エキサイト恋愛結婚
ゼロファクター
ゼロファクター
アトランティックトレード
為替ライフ
kakaku FX
kakaku FX
kakaku FX
ヘルニア
たるみ
肌荒れ
二日酔い
宿便
むくみ
低血圧
しみ
そばかす
つわり
ウィ アピシア
ウィ アピシア
ミッシーリスト
柿渋石けん
柿渋石けん
イングリッシュアドベンチャー
イングリッシュアドベンチャー
イングリッシュアドベンチャー
アルファメール
楽天オート
楽天オート
楽天オート
ビジ割
エコ割
北の大地の天然オリゴ糖
ビーグレン
ビーグレン
ビーグレン
ビーグレン
ビーグレン
ビーグレン
ビーグレン
楽天プレミアムカード
トリア
トリア
トリア
プロアクティブ
プロアクティブ
プロアクティブ 無料お試し
プロアクティブ
プロアクティブ
プロアクティブ
プロアクティブ
トマトの育て方
ビーグレン
茶のしずく
北の大地の天然オリゴ糖
オーネット
やずや
プロアクティブ
黒ずみ
猫背
貧血
フケ
イライラ
だるさ
セルライト
トラウマ
ものもらい
乾燥肌
敏感肌
かぶれ
勉強方法
空腹
カビ
迷惑電話
スズメバチ
外反母趾
下痢
五十肩
四十肩
エコカー
アイフルホーム
バイク王
バイク王
パルコカード
ダック 引っ越し
リーブ21
リーブ21
リーブ21
リーブ21
ノーローン
ノーローン
ノーローン
アットローン
アットローン
アットローン
てるみくらぶ
てるみくらぶ
てるみくらぶ
プロミス
プロミス
プロミス
ブルックスコーヒー
ブルックスコーヒー
ブルックスコーヒー
ブルックスコーヒー

Life Coaching

The first one is a family genealogy site. My parents had spent 25 years collecting the data and I thought it would be fun to make it into a web site. The second is about a hobby of mine, collecting illustrations from the zillions of editions of the Arabian Nights that are out there.
Law of Attraction Forum

The comments to this entry are closed.

Tidbits

The Long Tail by Chris Anderson

Notes and sources for the book

FREE was available in all digital forms--ebook, web book, and audiobook--for free shortly after the hardcover was published on July 7th. The ebook and web book were free for a limited time and limited to certain geographic regions as determined by each national publisher; the unabridged MP3 audiobook (get zip file here) will remain free forever, available in all regions.

Order the hardcover now!